Collars, tags and microchips: what a Toronto dog should wear

November 29, 2022 · Updated November 5, 2026

Collars, tags and microchips: what a Toronto dog should wear

Updated November 2026: this article first ran in November 2022 as “Which Collar Is Best For My Dog?” It is now a Toronto guide to the collar, the tags and the microchip, built on veterinary sources and the City's own rules. Withdrawn from the old version: that choke chains and prong collars are banned in Canada (there is no Canadian ban, and Toronto's 2017 ban was repealed within weeks); that the martingale is great for leash training (VCA Animal Hospitals says it is not a training tool); that rolled collars put too much pressure on the windpipe (we found no veterinary source); and a quotation attributed to the American Kennel Club in words it does not use.

Which collar is best for my dog?

It depends on the dog. The short answer:

  • Walks nicely on a loose leash, no health problems: a flat buckle collar, fitted snugly, carrying the City licence tag and an ID tag.
  • Pulls or lunges: a body harness for walks, and reward-based training. A tighter collar is not the fix.
  • Flat-faced (a pug, a bulldog), or has a windpipe, neck or eye problem: a harness for walks. A dog that coughs on the leash needs a vet visit, because a cough has several causes.
  • A head narrower than the neck (a greyhound, a whippet): a martingale collar for walks, fitted so the dog cannot back out of it, and taken off when you are not watching.
  • A long coat that mats: a rolled collar to carry the tags, and a harness for walking.

Whichever collar you choose, it also carries the licence tag, which Toronto requires your dog to wear at all times.

Flat collar, harness or martingale

A flat buckle collar is the everyday choice. VCA Animal Hospitals says it should sit securely without constricting, that a loose one can slip off, and that hard pulling against it can stress the delicate structures of the neck. Preventive Vet adds that walking on one is fine for a dog with good loose-leash manners.

A body harness spreads the pressure across the chest and shoulders instead of the throat. VCA calls it an excellent choice for dogs with tracheal disease or neck pain. A good fit does not limit the front legs or rub behind the elbows, and a loose one lets a dog back out. A front-clip harness lets gentle leash pressure turn the dog away from a distraction, though VCA notes that some designs sit across the shoulder joints and can restrict movement.

A martingale, or limited-slip, collar has a small second loop that tightens to a set limit when the leash pulls, so a dog whose head is narrower than its neck cannot slip out. VCA says it must be fitted so it prevents escape without choking, that it needs supervision because it can catch on the jaw or tangle in long hair, and that it is not recommended as a training tool. Preventive Vet's fit: two fingers snug, and tight enough when the loop closes that the dog cannot pull its head back through.

A head halter, such as a Gentle Leader or Halti, has one strap behind the ears and one around the muzzle, and steers the head. The Canadian Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA) lists head collars and front-clip harnesses among the humane tools for controlling a dog on walks. VCA adds conditions: introduce it gradually, because some dogs never accept one; never use it with a long line or a retractable leash; never tether a dog in one; and never jerk the leash, only brief gentle pressure and release. Preventive Vet does not recommend head halters for small dogs or dogs with thin necks and heads.

A rolled collar is round and does not catch long fur. Preventive Vet suggests one to carry the tags on dogs whose coats mat, with a harness for walking.

A breakaway collar opens under pressure if it catches on something. Preventive Vet suggests one for wear indoors. It is not a walking collar: VCA warns that a dog can escape if the leash is clipped to the breakaway ring, and that a two-ring model needs the leash attached to both.

On leashes, VCA prefers a standard one to a retractable. In Toronto the limit is two metres outside off-leash areas, so a retractable let out further than that is longer than the by-law allows.

How tight should a dog collar be?

Snug, with room for about two fingers flat between the collar and the neck, or one finger for a small dog. Sources differ on small dogs: one American Kennel Club page says one finger, while another AKC page and Preventive Vet say two.

Check a puppy's collar often, because puppies outgrow collars fast; every few days is a good habit, and every few weeks for an adult dog. A collar that has become too tight can cut into the neck and hide under the fur. If the skin under it looks red, sore or swollen, see your vet.

When to take the collar off

  • In the crate. A collar or a dangling tag can catch on the crate wire. Preventive Vet's advice: no collar in the crate, or a breakaway or lay-flat collar with no loops and no hanging tags, with your contact details embroidered on it.
  • Before rough play with other dogs. An AKC writer tells of a friend's puppy that died when an older dog's jaw caught in its buckle collar during play, and the advice is plain: if in doubt, remove the collar.
  • When nobody is watching. VCA warns that a collar can tangle on things like a cabinet handle. A harness should come off when you cannot watch the dog, it says, and a head halter is meant for use with the leash in your hand. Preventive Vet says not to leave a collar on a puppy that is unattended.

The by-law expects the licence tag on your dog at all times, so keep these breaks short and put the collar back on before the door opens: a dog without a collar carries no tag.

Dogs with airway, neck or eye problems

For flat-faced (brachycephalic) breeds such as pugs and bulldogs, VCA advises a harness that does not pull on the neck, because a collar can put undue pressure on it. VCA also says these dogs overheat easily because their ability to pant and cool themselves is compromised, and advises avoiding hot, humid conditions and controlling exercise. Severely affected dogs can collapse after exercise: if yours struggles to breathe or collapses, call your vet or an emergency clinic at once. For tracheal collapse, VCA says a collar can press on the windpipe and make the coughing worse, and recommends a harness.

A small study by Pauli and colleagues in 2006 measured eye pressure in 26 dogs and found it rose when pressure was applied through a collar, but not through a harness. It did not test dogs with eye disease and does not show that collars cause glaucoma, but the authors suggest a harness for dogs with weak or thin corneas, glaucoma or other eye conditions, especially during exercise. If your dog has any of these, ask your vet which to use.

Is there a ban on choke and prong collars in Toronto?

Not a general one. A ban on using a choke collar, choke chain, pronged collar or any similar device on a dog took effect on March 1, 2017, under By-law 102-2017, with martingale collars exempt. Council voted on March 28 and 29 to repeal it, and By-law 419-2017 deleted it on April 28, 2017. That section of Chapter 349 now reads “Reserved.”

What remains is a tethering rule: no one may keep an animal tethered where a choke collar, choke chain, pronged collar or similar device forms part of the tether. The City's dog-ownership page says martingale collars are permitted when tethering, though VCA says a dog in a martingale should be supervised. Our 2017 news story on the choke chain ban reported it when it came in; the ban did not last, so read that story as history.

Not banned is not the same as recommended. The CVMA strongly discourages choke, pinch and prong collars, and says remote shock collars are not necessary and cannot be used humanely. The BC SPCA does not support training devices that cause anxiety, fear, distress, pain or injury, and names choke chains, prong collars and shock collars among them. The AKC says corrective collars such as these can cause neck injury, pain and even strangulation. For a dog that pulls, these bodies point to a harness and reward-based training.

What Toronto requires your dog to wear

  • The licence tag, at all times. Every dog owned in Toronto must be licensed every year, and Chapter 349 says the owner must keep the licence tag securely fixed on the dog at all times. The City says licensed lost pets get home sooner. Fees are on the City's fees page; service animals are exempt.
  • A leash no longer than two metres anywhere off your own property, except in a designated off-leash area of a City park, where dogs must be licensed and vaccinated. The City's page adds that the leash must be securely attached to a collar or harness, and that tying a dog to a pole or a bike rack is not allowed.
  • At home, on a tether: no shorter than three metres, keeping the dog on your property, with no choke or prong device as part of it, and never unsupervised for more than an hour. That hour is the legal limit, not a safe one: a tether can tangle, so stay within sight.
  • The rabies certificate. Ontario requires dogs over three months old to be vaccinated against rabies, and Toronto Public Health says owners must keep the vet's certificate. Under Ontario's rabies regulation the vet who gives the shot also provides a rabies tag, and the tag's number goes on the certificate. You may hang it on the collar; we found no rule that requires it.

Why a microchip is not enough on its own

A microchip is a passive radio tag about the size of a large grain of rice, injected under the skin between the shoulder blades. It has no battery and no GPS. It holds only a number, which a scanner at a vet clinic or shelter reads; your details live in the registry where the chip was recorded.

A chip is the one identification that cannot fall off, but it needs a scanner and an up-to-date record, so it works best with a tag. A neighbour who finds your dog cannot read it; the City tells finders to report the dog to 311 and suggests bringing it to a vet clinic or animal shelter to be scanned. A chip can occasionally move, so the scanner is passed over the whole body. A tag is read on the sidewalk.

A chip is also only as good as its record. In a 2009 study of 7,704 microchipped animals in 53 American shelters, by Lord and colleagues, only 58% of the chips the shelters checked with a registry were registered, and more than a third of the animals whose owners could not be found had a wrong or disconnected phone number on file.

The CVMA's position on microchips covers the rest:

  • Choose a chip that meets the ISO 11784 and 11785 standards, implanted by a veterinarian.
  • Register it, and update the registry whenever you move or change your phone number.
  • Not every scanner reads every chip, so don't assume a lost dog's chip will be found.
  • Ask your vet to scan the chip at the yearly check-up.

Canada has several microchip registries rather than one, so keep the name of yours. Toronto Animal Services runs a Chip Truck that microchips pets with a current City licence. And if your dog is ever picked up at large, Chapter 349 requires you to have it microchipped within 24 hours of collecting it from the City.

What to put on the ID tag

Toronto Humane Society calls a tag the first line of defence, cheap and visible at once, and a chip the backup that will not fall off. Its advice for the tag: your pet's name, a current phone number and any essential medical information, on a secure collar. If your number changes, the tag needs to change too.

The research backs the tag. In an American study of 187 lost dogs by Lord and colleagues in 2007, 71% were recovered, and 18% of those came home through their licence tag. Dogs wearing a licence tag were more likely to be recovered. The study is American, but the point holds: a readable tag lets a finder call you on the spot.

If your dog goes missing

Call Toronto Animal Services at 416-338-PAWS (7297) or dial 311, with a photo, a description, your licence number and your microchip number. Ask your microchip company to confirm the phone number and address on the record. Check the City's Stray Animals Report, which lists animals found in the last 14 days. Under Chapter 349, a dog the City picks up is held for at least five days, not counting the day it came in or days the centre is closed, so call and visit early. Our guide for a missing cat in Toronto covers posters, the City's poster rules and reward scams.

How Petbook can help

A Petbook account is free, and each pet gets a page with its name and photo. The Petbook tag is a QR code on the collar. Whoever finds your dog scans it with a phone camera and sees that page, with a way to reach you, without an app or an account.

If your dog goes missing, Report lost on its page alerts your followers and creates a public alert page, live for 30 days, that you can share in Facebook groups. With a city and province on the alert, it also appears on the public lost pets board, where anyone can report a sighting without an account. Its Make a poster button prints a one-page poster with the photo and a QR code that opens the alert. While the dog is reported lost, a scan of its tag e-mails you, and its page shows a Tell their family link so whoever has your dog can let you know at once.

The Petbook tag is not identification: it is not a licence, a microchip or proof of ownership, and it goes on the collar beside the City tag, not instead of it. Join free and add your dog.

Sources

Petbook is loading…